Alan Milburn, Chair of the Social Mobility Commission (Credit: UK Government, Open Government License 3)
Alan Milburn, Chair of the Social Mobility Commission (Credit: UK Government, Open Government License 3)

Milburn Review: How Scotland can help more young people into work

Glasgow Chamber of Commerce is calling for swift action to cut youth hiring costs and a bigger role for Scotland’s

Facebook
X
LinkedIn

Subscribe to our daily newsletter

Why? Free to subscribe, no paywall, daily business news digest.

Glasgow Chamber of Commerce is calling for swift action to cut youth hiring costs and a bigger role for Scotland’s city regions in helping young people build the skills businesses need.

Scotland’s city regions could help more young people move from education into work by bringing employers, schools and training providers together, Glasgow Chamber of Commerce has said in response to the Milburn Review.

Alan Milburn’s independent review recommends reducing employer National Insurance costs for hiring young people, starting with retail and hospitality. It also proposes giving regional authorities in England a central role in delivering youth employment support. Glasgow Chamber wants Scotland’s city regions to play a similar role, with sustained funding to support young people as they move between education, training and work.

Alison McRae, senior director at Glasgow Chamber of Commerce, pointed to the Chamber’s work through the Scottish Government-funded Developing the Young Workforce initiative and its JPMorgan Chase-funded GROW programme. She said GROW had helped more than 400 young people from some of the region’s most deprived communities gain work experience with more than 140 employers.

On the proposed National Insurance relief, she said: “These sectors account for almost two in five jobs held by under-25s, and lower hiring costs would help more employers give young people their first break. We’d urge the UK Government to move quickly and set out how it will extend the relief to other sectors.”

Creating more first jobs

James Tuttiett, global transformation director at FDM Group, questioned whether the proposed incentives would go far enough. The review estimates that its employer measures could support around 170,000 additional job and apprenticeship opportunities, while its wider modelling suggests 500,000 extra opportunities across employment and education may be needed by 2036. The wider estimate includes education, so the two figures measure different things.

Tuttiett said businesses also needed to rethink junior roles as automation changes the work done by graduate developers, analysts and operations assistants.

He said: “Training pays off only when it’s fit for purpose, and there’s a job at the end of it.”

Sheila Flavell CBE, chief operating officer at FDM Group, called for lower hiring costs to be backed by structured training that includes AI skills.

She said: “Extending National Insurance relief to 21 to 24-year-olds in their first two years of work would help businesses to hire.”

Dr Joe Marshall, chief executive of the National Centre for Universities and Business, said employers, universities and local leaders should work together to ensure training reflects regional priorities and leads to real opportunities.

He said: “Ultimately, young people need a system that not only equips them for work, but creates genuine opportunities to put their skills to use.”

Making entry-level jobs easier to access

Keith Rosser, chair of the Better Hiring Institute, said employers risked shutting young people out by asking for experience they had not yet had the chance to gain.

He said: “We need a fundamental shift in how hiring is conducted, focusing less on arbitrary qualifications and years of experience, and more on whether someone has the skills and potential to do the job.”

Commenting separately on ONS labour market figures, he said: “The danger is that we’re making a broken recruitment system faster, rather than better at connecting the right people with the right jobs.”

Elizabeth Anderson, chief executive of the Digital Poverty Alliance, warned that a lack of access to laptops could limit young people’s education and employment prospects. In the charity’s research, almost a third of parents reported that their children had become more interested in attending college after receiving a laptop.

She said: “If we are serious about tackling youth economic inactivity, we must ensure young people have access to devices, connectivity and digital skills training.”

Helping young people stay and progress in work

Kristina Church, group head of sustainability at Aberdeen and chair of the Aberdeen Group Charitable Trust, backed pre-apprenticeships and meaningful work experience. She cited research showing that, among under-30s who were out of work but wanted a job, 37% reported a lack of suitable opportunities, 25% said available jobs did not offer the hours or flexibility they needed, and 24% faced transport or travel difficulties.

She said: “Success should be judged not just by how many young people enter employment, but by whether they can remain in work, progress and achieve lasting financial security.”

Calum Cooper, president of the Society of Pension Professionals, welcomed the review’s recognition of the case for lowering the minimum age and earnings threshold for automatic workplace pension enrolment, but warned against delaying reforms until 2031.

He said: “However, we should be seeking to support young people into their first jobs while also helping them build financial security for their later lives. These objectives should go hand in hand, rather than being considered as competing priorities.”

Facebook
X
LinkedIn

Related Articles

Varun Sarpangal, principal technical consultant (Credit: Marex)
Marex consultant gains Chartered Ergonomist status
Main construction begins on Lewis Hub transmission project
SSE opens new 640 person office space in Glasgow
Weir orders rise 8% in third quarter as group stays on track for 2026
CVC opens Edinburgh office with plans for 20 staff
Credit: ESP Group
ESP Group wins Female Leadership Award at Fast 50 awards

Other Articles from HGS

The Latest Stories